Press play
Listen to this episode
Plays here stream straight from our feed. Prefer your own app? Hit “Listen on Spotify,” or find us wherever you get your podcasts.In this episode
Trevor kicks things off unfiltered and Tom-less before the Golden Boys finally reunite for a sun-soaked love letter to Key West — Kermits key lime pie, the Little White House, and the sacred art of skipping the buoy line — with new AI co-host Madison steering the questions and a bachelor-party confession you won’t soon forget.
What they covered
Topics on deck
Season 3 reveal
Madison’s on-air debut
Key West Q&A
Kermits key lime pie
The Little White House
Southernmost point tip
Hemingway House detour
Bachelor-party disaster
Don’t miss
Moments worth the wait
- Solo and salty — Trevor opens alone, ribbing Tom’s legendary tardiness.
“Look at what kind of show is this? Like do you think Ed McMahon ever showed up late to the tonight show?”
- Season 3 revealed — a fresh season and a big count correction.
“December equals a new season for carnival cruising podcast away… the official start for season three is December 2nd.”
- Madison unmasked — listeners learn the new co-host is an AI.
“Madison is actually an AI. And she is actually joining us on this show for season three.”
- Tom’s hidden gem — the Little White House history lesson.
“Harry S Truman actually had a house… That’s where they signed the Key West agreement, which is what united the Department of the Navy and the Department of War into the Defense Department.”
- Skip the buoy line — Trevor’s pro tip for the famous photo.
“you can find the southernmost point bar… there’s a huge line to get a picture there. But you could just take a picture at the southernmost point bar.”
- Pie, unanimously — the key lime verdict is not close.
“Kermits. Yeah. 1000% Kermits.”
- Bachelor-party closer — the groom who vanished after refusing endless Fireball.
“We thought we had a hangover moment because we lost the groom.”
Golden nuggets
Running bits & lore born here
- Madison’s debut — the show’s AI producer joins on-air for the first time, launching the long-running “she’s secretly an AI” bit (Terminator, Skynet and Donnie Darko references included). Trevor’s running gag: “she threatened me with my search history. So she’s part of the show now.”
- Gary comes out ahead — when Madison throws a little shade, Trevor defends Gary warmly: “we can’t help the fact that Gary is better than Madison.”
- The retirement business plan — fishing guides trading on “over 50 years of experience doing other things.” Trevor: “That’s copyrighted by the way guys.”
- #WheresThomas — the tardiness bit gets a full workout as Trevor opens solo.
- Key West callback — a nod to the island being the Season 1 Episode 2 topic, now revisited in full.
- Hemingway mysteries — the six-toed cats and the “Love Muscle House, est. 1892” plaque near Hemingway’s spark a detour, with the Oct 28 costume contest teased.