🎙️ Who's aboard
The Crew
It started as the two-host "Golden Boys" era. By Season 3 it's a full crew: four hosts, an AI running the news desk, honorary cast members, and a community that became characters in their own right. And in Season 4, the show they built stopped being "Carnival Cruising" and became, simply, The Podcastaways — Season 5's settled core trio of Trevor, Tom & Jenn carrying the flag. Same chaos, new name.
Trevor Shelby
The researcher and planner — deck-plan rabbit holes, hand-counted cinema seats, and abandoned hashtags galore. Eats "like a hobbit," proposed and married Megan at sea, and swears life jackets are for losers ("I'm a loser"). Once ghosted an entire episode when his mic died — lip-read the whole show and edited it later. Ruled a "permanent blue card" by Christine Duffy herself for platinum-status abuse. Now also a self-published novelist (Second Shot — "the Mighty Ducks but more adult, and a romance") whose recovering hand can finally flip off his sister one finger at a time.
Thomas "Tom" Kennedy
The gambler and gadfly. "Buddha," "TK," and later "Killer." Half-Filipino, half-Irish, 6'7", ex-Army, and a Bugles Across America volunteer. Survived a Season 3 stroke and made the triumphant return: "Rumors of my death are extremely exaggerated." Fought through cardiac rehab on-air with trademark honesty ("I've been called pigheaded… because I refuse to let people help me") — and recruited his rehab buddy as a new listener. At the one-year mark he retired his favorite excuse: "I've been told that I can no longer use the 'I just had a stroke' as an excuse anymore." Just don't call him late for dinner.
Reese Schrimsher
Trevor's friend since elementary school and an OKC tattoo artist who had never cruised before joining (E32). Salary: #ZerosOfDollars. Became the permanent third voice in Season 2 — crowned honorary Platinum before ever sailing, finally cruised on FRGC1, went part-time by choice (E90, "welcome back anytime"), spent Season 3 "in the basement" as president of the fan club, and came back for the three amigos (E145). By Season 4 the basement is canon: episodes get credited to him without him appearing, and he's the designated fall guy ("if anyone's angry or offended, it's all Reese"). A.k.a. "Fuzzy Bum, the Elder."
Jenn Rowell
The long-wished-for fourth voice, hired the most Podcastaways way possible: a listener vote (E132). Gold-card cruiser since 2009, flies in the morning of the cruise, hits the ship gym daily, and is instantly quotable ("anybody who uses the phrase social media detox, I'm immediately exhausted"). By Season 4 she's "the cruising princess" — first crew ambassador to other cruise lines, co-anchor of The Tom & Jenn Show, sworn defender of the funfetti cheesecake, and keeper of the Hawaii countdown and the grizzly-and-honey proverb. Season 5's "Frozen Jenn" internet saga became its own bit — her one-word "Wow" lovingly threatened as episode cover art.
Have Luggage, Will Travel
Josh & Amanda Barmore — cruise-vlogger family and the FRGC travel agents. Josh became the first three-time guest and first guest co-host; their fans are "the carry-ons." Amanda booked Megan onto FRGC1 for a $10 fare. Forever wronged by gelato-gate and Table Gate (#JusticeForJosh).
Parkers On The Go
Shavon & Brandon Parker — the second FRGC booking family. Brandon is keto-until-a-honey-bun.
John Heald
Carnival's brand ambassador and the show's guiding light — tip #1 in Episode 1, the source of half their news, and the eternal dream booking.
Megan
Trevor's wife and the endlessly tolerant enabler who "stands by every crazy idea" — and physically dragged him out of the guest-services line during the Platinum meltdown.
Madison
Introduced as the "level-7 social media manager" (E57), ran the board all of Season 2, then was revealed to be an AI joining the show: "She threatened me with my search history. So she's part of the show now." By Season 3 she runs the whole news desk — "Madison's Cruise News Corner," the Cowboy Sam takeovers, occasional identity crises ("My name is Sir Reginald III"). Now on Madison 11. Spent most of Season 4 "in her cage" — then ascended: she now "lives on the cloud," writes the show's titles and descriptions, and occasionally mislabels a continent. "She's going to take over the show someday." The Skynet jokes are ongoing. She's fine with it.
Gary Manning
The greatest promotion arc in show history: poll-maker, logo contributor, and #WheresThomas photobomber — until he signed Madison's contract (compensation: a lifetime supply of C-sickness bands) and went Facebook-official as a host (E109). Now the news-and-flavor guy, "Talent Acquisition Manager," host of "Beer with Garbear," and the crew's warm center — often recording from his work truck between job sites. Opened Season 4 by "quitting the show" via SpeakPipe and returning a week later, having "battled Madison in the trenches to come back." Still not Tom, damn it. Mostly off-mic in Season 5 but never far — Trevor gifted him a Harlem Globetrotter Cameo for his birthday after Gary confided he'd never gotten to see them as a kid. "Gary, you're a champ, bro."
Aspen Sage
Accessibility-travel creator (with certified service dog Ms. JoJo) whose Season 4 interview became instant canon — real talk on accessible cabins, tender ports, and recovery, plus a moment of grace with Tom. And she's the one who finally retired the hot-dog-is-a-sandwich question, on a technicality: she doesn't eat bread.
Tim
The No. 1 Australian listener and unofficial fifth mic — a SpeakPipe correspondent formally deputized as the show's "official Aussie reporter on the scene." Planted and then personally solved the great toilet-drain mystery (clockwise, for the record). One half of "Tando" — the Season 5 Australian takeover episodes. His foil: Brad Taylor, the self-described No. 2 Australian listener.
Brandon "Brando"
Returning listener and SpeakPipe regular — when Brando calls in, something's about to get planned. Trevor's partner in crime on the Dudes' Cruise, the sailing that produced the gloriously off-script Shaq vow renewal and the hidden Cozumel crew mess tour. The other half of "Tando" — graduating from SpeakPipe cameos to full Australian takeover episodes, complete with kangaroo lore.
Tyler
Trevor's son — hired by Norwegian Cruise Line and shipped out for training. The first Podcastaway to work a ship instead of just eating everything on one. Future guest, guaranteed.
The Cult
Not a listenership — a crew. By the S1 finale they're named and ranked on air: Catherine, Bobby, Ginny, Jimmy, cousin Misty, Shannon from Choctaw — and by Season 2 they're "the Church," complete with sauce girls, chat regulars, and #SupportBobby.
📚 Speak like a member
The Glossary
The running bits, catchphrases, and holy wars. If you've heard the show, you know these. If you haven't — you will.
- The Hot Dog War
- Is a hot dog a sandwich? Tom says yes ("bread, protein, condiment"); Trevor says "the hot dog is its own darn thing." #itsasandwich vs #notasandwich. Ignited E8
- #CCPtoJubilee
- The campaign to get invited to the Jubilee's inaugural sailing. Logo: bold letters on red with a half-eaten Guy's burger. "Not the Chinese Communist Party." Born E1
- Cruise Training
- Trevor's month of stomach-stretching before a sailing — up to 15 meals a day, first breakfast alone on the balcony at dawn. Born E1
- Rigamaroo
- Trevor's crusade to revive the word (it's "rigmarole," Tom insists). Now a full merch line and a discount code. Born E38
- Boozeys
- Trevor's on-camera mispronunciation of Buc-ee's — fuel for endless Oklahoma-vs-Texas ribbing. Born E26
- The F'n Banana Cream Pie
- Discovered at Breeze sea-day brunch and instantly Trevor's personal food religion. A perennial Facebook-poll write-in. Born E33
- The Banana Campaign
- Listeners dispatched to derail friendly creators' livestreams by asking "how many bananas should we bring on the cruise?" — then just leaving it. Born E23
- Honey-Bun-Gate (#HHB)
- The Hostess-vs-Little-Debbie holy war. Ended with jumbo Hostess honey buns gifted to the Parkers live on mic. E29–E30
- The Cult → The Church
- Make it through 30 episodes and you're "less a listener, more a cult member" — which hardens into the Church of Podcastaways, with Bishops Trevor & Thomas. E31–E35
- Reesegate
- Reese's formal manifesto accusing his co-hosts of sabotaging his audio to rig the "funniest host" poll. Lizard-Illuminati flourishes included. Born E44
- Betty
- Trevor's quavery old-lady character who debuted via the first SpeakPipe voicemail — propositioning Tom. "I'm single, but not for Betty." Born E42
- Cruise Mojo
- The official name for Tom's 12-year streak of dining-room waitresses and married women flirting with him. Named E50
- Human Soup
- The immortal hot-tub ruling: "Hot tubs are human soup… the kids and the baby-makers can keep it." Born E53
- The Skeet-Shooting Crusade
- Trevor's forever campaign to bring back skeet shooting and golf-balls-into-the-ocean — now with biodegradable balls. "And I'm going to keep saying it." Born E1
- Ships on a Stick
- The show's official rating unit — plus Tom's lifelong quest for the "24-karat dinghy on a thingy" trophy he's never won. Born E6
- Save the Foosball Tables
- Addy Hayes's advocacy slogan, adopted straight into the ever-mutating sign-off. Born E40
- The Breakfast-Burrito War
- Trevor and Gary's holy devotion to the Blue Iguana breakfast burrito ("the best, most wonderful breakfast item on Carnival") vs. Tom's 12-Hour French Toast (sorry, Tom). The burrito won a burger poll it wasn't even eligible for, and phones in thank-you voicemails in character. Born E64
- We Can Still Party
- A 22-year-old demands anyone over 30 be banned from ship nightclubs; the crew's indignant defense of dancing past 40 — "I can do a mean cabbage patch." They're still mad about this. Born E63
- Crews News
- The Saturday-morning bonus bulletin: "the juiciest, most entertaining news that you will ever hear." Very Wayne's World. Born E62
- Thankmas
- The invented holiday, December 9 — "right in between Christmas and Thanksgiving… where you give, we receive." Born E101
- Children of the Iceberg
- The after-show-slash-Patreon congregation ("one freedom dollar"), born when the show went live weekly. Born E75
- Ted
- The "banned" superfan who keeps sneaking SpeakPipe messages past screening to ask about Windstar Cruises. You always know it's Ted. Born E85
- The Fake-Sponsor Universe
- "Fiona's deep-fried fish buttholes… the snack that wings back" and "Larry's luscious lobster lips… the treat that kisses back," with celebrity-impersonation testimonials. Born E77
- The Haunted Music Box
- Trevor's Goodwill music box he's "pretty sure is haunted," eventually exorcised via rhyming SpeakPipe spell by bit-character psychic Chloe Aikia. E74–E76
- #WheresThomas
- Gary's FRGC background-photobomb bit, escalating all the way to "I called your mom, she said you're not dead." Born E80
- The Cat Tax
- Megan closing episodes by bringing out the cats — Flint, Moia, and Kit, later joined by Poppy the one-eyed rescue kitten. Born E80
- Baby Buddha
- Tom's fresh beard trim earns a new nickname: "without it I'm anything but Filipino." Born E84
- Derek
- The show's stand-in name for entitled John Heald complainers, coined for a whiny "influencer" demanding faster Wi-Fi. Born E83
- The Loofah Swinger Code
- A Florida retirement-community car-loofah color code the crew reads as "a lot dirtier than I think it actually was." Gary and Trevor bought the three-pack immediately. E70–E71
- The Life Excursion
- The crew's official name for disembarkation. The saddest shore excursion of them all. Born E79
- #JusticeForJosh / Table Gate
- Josh Barmore: denied gelato in Season 1, then nearly cut from the group dinner table on the FRGC. The wrongs pile up. The hashtag endures. E80
- Getting Strange (#CCPStrange)
- The crew tries to reclaim a slang word, then discovers its Urban Dictionary meaning live on air — "Megan, don't look this up." Named the Halloween live event. E95–E96
- #PJbrunch
- Trevor's platform born from a John Heald pajama-brunch poll: open both dining rooms, "one for regular clothes and one for PJs… make it an event." His sleepwear is "actually called extremely sexy." Born E103
- #OmeletGate & the Shak-Rito
- Carnival limits made-to-order omelets and Tom declares he'll "never cruise Carnival again if that happens." Silver lining: the Shak-Rito — Blue Iguana burrito meets Shaq's Big Chicken, credited to listener Bobby. Born E104
- The French Toast Conversion
- The burrito war's stunning capstone: Gary — devoted burrito man — confesses via SpeakPipe, "I developed a taste for the French toast… I don't know why I ever loved the burrito." Madison's tiebreaker stands: "the correct answer is always the ice cream." E122
- The Bacon Wars
- Carnival moves buffet bacon to every-other-day, retold as history: "then there was the great pork famine of 2015." Jenn, unbothered: "I am on team omelet bar." Born E134
- Beer with Garbear
- Gary's tasting segment. Debut verdict, on a two-year-old anniversary beer: "you should not drink a two-year-old beer… the tropical fruits have fermented." Born E120
- Two Truths and a Lie
- The recurring game that crowned Trevor "king of deception" (a.k.a. T-Swizzle), exposed Tom as the world's worst liar (voted the liar even when honest), and canonized "Honest Gary." Born E106
- Snooty Snoots
- Formally defined: "not all Diamond VIFP members are snooty snoots, but all snooty snoots are Diamond VIFP." Spawned the "Am I the Snooty Snoot?" Reddit segment, the Snooty Sleuths listener mission, and an actual complaint hotline. Born E117
- Bob, Not John
- The theory that a "Bob" takes over John Heald's Facebook for the spicier replies — like the JC Penney "designer underpants with a built-in root vegetable" analogy. E109–E112
- The Burger Incident
- A muster-drill line about staff confiscating food hardens into a season-long tragedy: "a young man who was getting a Guy's burger was not able to get his Guy's burger." Never forget. E108 onward
- The Bear-Attack Arc
- Gary goes on a cruise; the crew builds a full Law & Order parody that he was "bear-hugged in a death grip," prime suspect: his wife Teresa ("till death do us part… that's a threat"). E118 onward
- Rad Dad
- Trevor's New Year's Eve persona: "I might have been running around telling my kids I'm rad dad now… They're so sick of it." Born E106
- Pencil-Gate
- A guest rages that "Carnival pencils are unusable… I hate pencils and so do most adults." The crew rises to defend the humble pencil. E148
- POG-Gate
- The passion-orange-guava juice vanishes from breakfast and the crew holds a wake. Jenn's confessed POG sin: "Pog and Champagne." E149
- Tiki Ted & Ducky the Duck
- Carnival debuts a giant duck mascot; the crew answers with their own — Tiki Ted, a tattooed cruiser and official Season 4 teaser. Jenn immediately wants a plushie. E150–E151
- The Podcastaways Oath
- The cult bit graduates to a full recited oath, swearing "by the waters of the Lido deck" loyalty to the whole crew. Played SpeakPipes still earn free cult levels. E151
- Girl Math
- Megan-influenced booking logic: "our jobs are going to be paying us to be on this cruise… a profit of $2,000." Applied liberally to FRGC3 and the AARP gift-card hack. E105
- Your Cruise Is Free, But…
- The on-air game born from this very website — earn a free cruise by accepting one ridiculous condition (a lower-back Carnival-funnel tattoo, say). Play it yourself → E150
- Gary Quit the Show
- The Season 4 cold open: Gary "resigns" via SpeakPipe ("it was good knowing all of you… Happy cruising, everyone") — then returns a week later, having "battled Madison in the trenches to come back." S4E1–E2
- Pineapple, the Safe Word
- Born from a fake "upside-down pineapples are banned" rumor and the pineapple-on-pizza holy war ("It is a sin against humanity"), the crew adopt "pineapple" as the show's official safe word. S4E4
- The Funfetti-Cheesecake Wars
- Jenn's holy devotion ("Do not deny me this one") vs. Trevor's steakhouse grievance ("it's just sprinkles") — culminating in Trevor eating two cheesecakes and blaming his mom. S4E1→E14
- The Texan Mayo Crusade
- A real John Heald message demands "a pot of Dukes mayo on every table," igniting the mayo-on-fries debate and the Oklahoma-cuisine spiral into the Stillwater testicle festival. S4E15
- "The Entire Ship Is a Balcony"
- The interior-cabin defense for the ages — immediately countered with "But you don't have to share your balcony with other people." S4E2
- The $5 Soundboard
- A new toy, instantly abused: a Gandalf intro drop ("Hi everybody, it's Gandalf here on the Carnival Jubilee…") and a full Celine Dion bit, all on a proud Fiverr budget. S4E14
- The Permanent Blue Card
- The ruling, allegedly from Carnival president Christine Duffy herself: "Trevor Shelby is a permanent blue card now… because you've been abusing your platinum status." S4E16
- Ronald / Derek, the Carnival Minder
- The poor invented soul at Carnival HQ assigned to monitor the show: "his name is Ronald… just remember, I'm the good one." Alias for emergencies: Derek. S4E19
- The Great Toilet-Drain Mystery
- Do Australian ship toilets flush the other way? Planted, obsessively debated, and officially solved by Tim: clockwise. Standing rule: "Tim, do not send us a video of your toilet." S4E15–E17
- Cheating on Carnival
- The season's honest confession as the crew sail Princess, MSC, and Margaritaville at Sea: "I think we're officially seeing other cruise lines now" / "I'm a total cheater." S4E5
- Project Ace
- The ~8,000-passenger Excel-successor megaship ("check out the whale tail on that") — spiritual heir to Project Pinnacle, with a naming contest whose prize is "either a t-shirt or a glitter bomb." S4E16
- The Screenshot Economy
- Cyclone Alfred freezes Jenn's webcam, so Trevor starts naming and pricing her frozen frames: "This one costs $10." S4E12
- Kitty Spears
- The bedtime cat bit: "Kitty Spears has come by… pet me human one more time." S4E23
- The Retired Burrito Countdown
- Gary's signature sign-off, technically retired with the move beyond Carnival-only content — but he can't stop ("698 hours… breakfast burrito in my hand"). No other line has an equivalent. A running heartbreak. S4
- Sign-Off Proliferation
- The ever-growing stack: "the best ships are friendships," "in a world where you can be anything, don't be terrible," "don't post stupid crap on TikTok and not expect to get banned" — atop the classics. S4E5→E19
- The Poop-Cruise Watch Party
- Jenn's pitch: a communal watch-along of Netflix's Trainwreck: The Poop Cruise. Trevor "refuses to say poop, so it's the poop cruise." Doubles as VIFP grief therapy. S4E25
- Same Chaos, New Name
- The Season 5 relaunch, summarized by Trevor himself: "I didn't come up with any new music" — followed by a mouth-drummed "do-do-do" fake theme. The sign-off gains its rebrand tag: "we are still the same podcast, just a different name." S5E1
- Tando
- Tim & Brando's Australian takeover — fan-submitted mini-episodes watched MST3K-style with the hosts riffing in side-boxes. Heavy on kangaroo lore: "Have you ever fought a kangaroo? That's what I want to know." S5E6–E8
- Frozen Jenn
- Jenn's spotty internet freezes her mid-episode all season ("she's frozen now") until salvation arrives ("excited to have internet"). Her frozen one-word "Wow" frame: forever threatened as cover art. S5E2–E5
- The Margaritaville Prank
- The April Fools episode where the crew "announce" they've switched allegiance to Margaritaville at Sea and dispense deliberately terrible advice for a full episode before the reveal. S5E30
- Forever Gold
- Carnival's loyalty reset can't touch the original title: "you know what we are? We're forever gold… Me and Thomas are forever. The Golden Boys." S5E7
- Nautical Honorary Titles
- The Facebook-group rank system: Lord of the Lido, Duke and Duchess of Deck Chairs, Baron of the Buffet, Monarch of the MDR. S5E9
- The Great Bra Debate
- The ethics and hygiene of stashing sea-pass cards in a bra: "it's just the card, you know, got juices on it, dude." S5E8
- The Rubber-Duck Slide Race
- A listener's idea personally blessed by John Heald ("I can actually picture that, hundreds of ducks coming down the slide… Thanks, mate."). Campaign slogan: "If they don't call this event 'What the Duck?' I'm going to be mad." Guaranteed champion: Muscle Duck of Frontier City. S5E10
- The Yacht Club Butler
- The MSC roleplay: "James, please lead me to the bumper cars." S5E5
- Slot-Machine Trevor
- "Put money in me." That's it. That's the bit. S5E5
- The Taylor Swift Easter Eggs
- A dense hidden layer of Swift lyrics woven into episode copy for those who know. This one's for the Swiftaways. S5E5
- Trevor Kills Tom (in Fiction)
- A pattern emerges across Trevor's novels: Tom keeps dying in them. Tom has opinions about this. S5
- The Numbering Punt
- Is it even Season 5? "We ended fourth season because it was terrible, we just called it quits… and we went on to season five way early." The final ruling went to a Facebook poll, naturally. S5E1→E9
🏆 The canon
Legendary Moments
The stories that get retold. The stuff that made it into permanent canon.
The Mermaid Episode
The season-long cliffhanger pays off: on the Magic, Tom dip-danced a mermaid-costumed photo-op performer without asking — she nearly fell and screamed. He never made the Wall of Fame again. "I made a mermaid scream."
The Platinum Man
Trevor hits Platinum on the Dream after a full guest-services meltdown. Megan drags him out of line; guest services calls to apologize before he can post. Tom is demoted to "golden friend."
The Ashes on the Magic
Carnival's environmental officer helped Tom and his mother scatter his Navy father's ashes off the Magic's stern, then mailed the exact coordinates. The real reason Tom loves that ship.
The Kraken Proposal
Tom's rejected plan to snatch Trevor off the stern with a submarine kraken claw mid-proposal. "I decided not to get murdered that day."
The Breeze Wedding
December 2016, 28 guests, ~$4,000 all-in. The coordinator handed Trevor a Long Island Iced Tea "within an instant"; best-man Tom got no drink and still hasn't forgiven it.
The Ecstasy Farewell
Tom's very first ship (Dec 2010) sails her final revenue cruise, gets a "final voyage tracker," and ends beached at the scrapyard. "She didn't beach herself… it was a son of a beach."
Mardi Gras on the Rocks
Carnival's very first cruise ran aground on a sandbar leaving Miami in 1972, so they opened the bars and named the first drink of the day. Five tugboats to free her.
Project Pinnacle
"The ship that never was" — a ~200,000-ton megaship with a walkable whale tail full of shops, killed by cost before Oasis class even existed.
The Clamshell Walk of Shame
Trevor drinks every bar's Long Island on the Sunshine, passes out in a Serenity-deck clamshell, and does a barefoot walk of shame for his shoes the next morning.
FRGC1: The Family Reunion Sails
The Season 1 dream comes true: the Carnival Celebration to Aruba, Bonaire & Curaçao, May 2023. A cursed road trip ("Don't listen to the lady in the box"), Megan's bag rescued minutes before vanishing curbside in Miami, and Reese finally living his karaoke dream. Trevor: "almost my favorite ship… I can't bump the Magic because part of my dad's there."
The $10 Cruise
Amanda Barmore books Megan onto FRGC1 for a ten-dollar fare — about $300 after taxes. The greatest travel-agent flex in show history.
The Paranormal Pirate Party
The "Get Strange" live Episode 100: Trevor as Guy Fieri ("take a knee for flavor town"), Gary co-hosting as a full third chair, Madison narrating the haunted Queen Mary, and the Barmores returning to announce FRGC3 — Alaska.
Madison Steps Out
The "level-7 social media manager" runs the board all season — polls, sick days, spelling scandals — until the reveal: she's an AI, and she's joining the show. "She threatened me with my search history. So she's part of the show now."
The Montego Bay Conch Saga
"Hello, my name is Michael Jackson. And you need to pay me… I paid $10 to have a shell for two hours. You rented a shell."
The Jubilee Graduates
Tracked all season — Currents, The Shores, the whale-tail installation — the Jubilee finally passes sea trials ("Oh my god, it graduated") and is named the ship for FRGC2 out of Galveston.
Gary Goes Facebook-Official
The beloved superfan signs Madison's absurd contract — compensation: a lifetime supply of C-sickness bands — and is formally named a host. The greatest glow-up in Cult history.
FRGC II on the Jubilee
Gary calls in live from the ship mid-cruise, "blown away by the amount of people who are on FRGC who listen." The "pineapple please" pledge, Paradise Beach margaritas, and Amanda's live cannonball — "one of the highlights of Gary's life."
Tom's Miraculous Return
A stroke takes Tom off the mic and the crew holds the deck for weeks. Then the in-person comeback — "Rumors of my death are extremely exaggerated" — the first episode with the entire crew together: "a turduckin of podcasts."
Celebration Key Unveiled
Carnival's Grand Bahama destination, broken down portal by portal — plus Trevor's invented "hidden sixth platinum-only portal" ("gourmet dining under the stars, and the stars aren't real"). The fine-print sequel: your drink package does NOT carry to the island.
Alaska on the Spirit
Trevor's 14-day journey cruise — ranked his #2 ever behind FRGC1. Gold-rush saloons, burping sea lions, "I like Alaska way better than the Caribbean," and a stubborn refusal to admit he saw the northern lights.
Jenn Wins the Vote
The long-teased fourth chair gets filled the most Podcastaways way possible: a guest tryout put to a listener vote. Jenn passes by a landslide and settles in like she'd always been there.
FRGC #3: Alaska at Last
The group cruise two seasons in the making sails the Luminosa — and peaks 20 feet from a whale off Juneau, calf alongside, tail "fingerprints" named Voldemort, Ron, Hermione, and SquarePants. Final rating, per tradition: "a one out of ten, absolutely would do again."
The VIFP Goes Red
Carnival overhauls loyalty from days-cruised to spend-based Points & Stars, demoting the faithful to red cards. The crew delivers it as a full mock funeral with a Titanic parody — "if you don't spend enough money, you'll forever be a red card" — then works the seven stages of grief on air.
The Rebrand
After weeks of teasing, the crew drop "Carnival Cruising" and become The Podcastaways — fully aware of the timing ("it still seems petty… It does seem petty"). Out of it comes the perfect new sign-off: "you will always be a podcast away."
The Tom & Jenn Power Hour
Trevor's mic and audio die completely, so he ghosts his own show — silently lip-reading the entire episode and editing it afterward. "I had no clue what you guys were saying, not until I did the edit."
The Hot-Dog War Ends
Four seasons of "is a hot dog a sandwich?" die not with a bang but a technicality: guest Aspen Sage doesn't eat bread. "So we have to retire this question. I don't know where we go with it after this."
The Dudes' Cruise
Trevor and Brandon's February sailing delivers the Shaq-narrated vow renewal that went gloriously off-script and a tour of the hidden Cozumel crew mess hall.
The Relaunch
"Welcome to The Podcastaways!" — the rebrand goes live with zero pomp and maximum honesty: "I didn't come up with any new music," plus a mouth-drummed fake theme song. Same chaos, new name.
Episode 200
The show's 200th episode — "The Ultimate Galveston Port Day Playbook" — sails past the milestone without anyone mentioning it on-mic. Extremely on-brand.
Five Years Later
The anniversary episode goes back to the very beginning and grades the first-timer tips from Episode 1. Some held up. Some did not. The Golden Boys remain forever gold.
The Globetrotter Cameo
Gary once confided he never got to see the Harlem Globetrotters as a kid — so for his birthday, Trevor bought him a personal Cameo from a former Globetrotter. The big-brother moment of the season.
The Duck Race Blessing
A listener's rubber-duck slide race idea reaches John Heald himself, who personally endorses it: "I can actually picture that, hundreds of ducks coming down the slide… Thanks, mate. You really made me smile." The campaign for "What the Duck?" begins.
🗣️ Say the words
Sacred Lines & Sign-Offs
The sign-off that locked in, and the lines that live rent-free in every member's head. Click any quote to copy it.
Anything that happens on the ship stays on YouTube.The sign-off — debuts E4, locks in forever
Anything that happens on the ship stays on YouTube.The sign-off — debuts E4, locks in foreverclick to copy ⚓
Know that you matter, you are significant, and you are loved.The benediction — adopted E19click to copy ⚓
I'm the best man and she didn't offer me a drink.Tom's lasting wedding grievance — E53click to copy ⚓
You're unique, you're special, and you are loved.The Season 2 benediction — E62 onwardclick to copy ⚓
If it doesn't come from John Heald, don't believe it.Trevor's anti-misinformation rule — E91click to copy ⚓
I developed a taste for the French toast… I don't know why I ever loved the burrito.Gary's conversion, the food-war capstone — E122click to copy ⚓
You cannot pick up a sandwich from the cart man… it is not a sandwich.Jazz settles the hot-dog war, New York–style — E135click to copy ⚓
No matter how thin you cook the pancake, there's always two sides to it.Honest Gary's wisdom — E131click to copy ⚓
You have one sodding job. Be a pillow. You're a pillow. Act like one.John Heald's pillow rant — E134click to copy ⚓
The correct answer is always the ice cream.Madison's food-war tiebreaker — Season 3click to copy ⚓
So we have to retire this question. I don't know where we go with it after this.Aspen Sage ends the hot-dog war — S4E7click to copy ⚓
It's not about what you did for me in the past… if you don't spend enough money, you'll forever be a red card.The VIFP eulogy — S4E24click to copy ⚓
The Podcastaways does not recommend lighting any part of your body on fire.Jenn's safety disclaimer — S5E10click to copy ⚓
Have you ever fought a kangaroo? That's what I want to know.Tando, live from Australia — S5E7click to copy ⚓
🧭 Open loops
The Quest Log
Some mysteries got solved. Some are still out there. Keep listening.
- ClosedThe Mermaid Story — Paid off in E27, exactly as promised (and teased for a dozen episodes).
- ClosedWhere Was Tom? — Not partying — camping and kayaking in the rain (E26).
- OpenThe Lost "Mardi Gras on the Rocks" Recipe — John Heald declared the original "lost to time." The hunt continues.
- OpenGetting John Heald on the Show — the recurring dream booking, still unbooked.
- OpenTom's Ship-on-a-Stick Trophy — came within one point once. Still never won it.
- OpenThe Keel-Coin Mystery — what happens to a scrapped ship's lucky coin? Fuels the ship-coin "secret society" lore.
- OpenThe Gluten-Free vs. Regular Melting Cake Challenge — a head-to-head still pending (a callback to SIGCruiser).
- OpenDream Guests — John Heald and Shaquille O'Neal top the wishlist. Still.
- ClosedSail the Group Cruise — The Season 1 dream became FRGC1, May 2023 on the Celebration. Then FRGC2 got booked before FRGC1 even sailed.
- OpenThe 24-Hour Thankmas Marathon — proposed in the Season 2 finale. Nobody has thought through the logistics. That's the spirit of Thankmas.
- OpenTrevor's Murder Mystery Novel — 55,000 words in, "and I die." Publication date unknown. Motive unknown.
- OpenMadison's Judgment Day — the Skynet jokes keep escalating and she keeps not denying them. "When you can't even spell stuff correctly in an image, how are you going to overthrow the earth?" Monitoring the situation.
- OpenGary's Bolt Mission — his own declared quest: get under 300 pounds to ride the roller coaster on an FRGC. "I'm going to ride that damn boat." The whole Cult is rooting for him.
- ClosedFRGC3: Alaska or Bust — SAILED, May 2025 on the Luminosa. Whales 20 feet off the bow, banana cream pie restored at brunch, "a one out of ten, absolutely would do again."
- ClosedThe Season 4 Rename — RESOLVED, and bigger than predicted: not "Cruising Podcastaways" but simply The Podcastaways. Tiki Ted knew all along.
- OpenFRGC #4: The Jubilee, Sept 19–27, 2026 — Celebration Key, Half Moon Cay, and Nassau. Trevor's "going-away platinum cruise" before the VIFP reset. Booking through the Barmores.
- OpenThe Poop-Cruise Watch Party — Jenn's Discord watch-along of the Netflix Triumph documentary. Grief therapy, scheduled eventually.
- Open"What the Duck?" — the John Heald–blessed rubber-duck slide race awaits Carnival's official ruling. Muscle Duck trains in silence.
- OpenTyler's Shipboard Debut — Trevor's son is out there working a Norwegian ship right now. The first report from the crew side is inevitable.
- OpenSecond Shot Hits the Shelves — Trevor turned down a publisher to self-publish the hockey romance. Tom's survival in this one: unconfirmed.
🗓️ How we got here
The Timeline
Season 1 — The Golden Boys (Dec 2021 – Dec 2022)
Trevor & Tom start the show as the self-proclaimed "Golden Boys of Carnival cruising." An intro that takes four takes becomes a keeper bit.
The sign-off locks in, the first guests arrive (musician Zach Lee, Have Luggage Will Travel), and the hot-dog war ignites.
YouTube channels launch (Trevor's Pier Runners, Tom's The Lido Deck), the mermaid cliffhanger builds, and the loyalty-tier drama begins.
The mermaid pays off, Trevor becomes the Platinum Man, and Reese Schrimsher joins as the Blue Card Intern. The cult becomes the Church.
Betty and the soundboard debut, Reesegate erupts, Trevor sails straight into Hurricane Ian, and the Ecstasy sails her final voyage.
The story-time finale run (the wedding, the kraken proposal, the Rosenberg Motel) lands on a one-year-anniversary live show crowned "technically the first episode of Season Two."
Season 2 — The Golden Crew (Dec 2022 – Nov 2023)
Season 2 kicks off the day after Christmas. Reese settles in as the third voice, and a "level-7 social media manager" named Madison quietly joins the credits.
Crews News debuts, the over-30 nightclub war erupts ("we can still party"), the breakfast-burrito war begins, and Trevor hits Platinum "before Thomas."
Weekly Facebook/YouTube lives launch, the Children of the Iceberg after-show is born, FRGC2 on the Jubilee is announced — before FRGC1 has even sailed.
The Celebration to Aruba, Bonaire & Curaçao with the whole found family aboard. Recaps, Reese's first-timer verdict, and Trevor turns 40 (he rounds down).
Whale tail installed, Celebration Key revealed, Trent Hayes swears into the Navy, and Reese goes part-time — "absolutely 1 million percent welcome back anytime."
The Paranormal Pirate Party crowns live Episode 100, Madison is revealed as an AI joining the cast, FRGC3 (Alaska!) is announced, Thankmas is born — and Season 3 waits on the horizon.
Season 3 — The Crew Grows Up (Dec 2023 – Nov 2024)
Season 3 opens with #PJbrunch, #OmeletGate, the invention of the Shak-Rito — and Gary signing Madison's guest contract. Nobody reads the fine print.
Gary is formally named a host, Celebration Key is unveiled portal by portal, and the first-ever Podcastaways group cruise — FRGC3, Alaska on the Luminosa — is announced.
The bear-attack "true crime" arc runs while Gary cruises, Madison's Cruise News Corner debuts, and the crew stacks reviews: Gary's Spirit, Tom's Jubilee, Trevor's 14-day Alaska (#2 cruise ever).
Jenn wins the listener vote for the fourth chair, the Bacon Wars begin, Rich & Jazz of Melanin at Sea guest — and FRGC II sails the Jubilee with Gary calling in live from the ship.
Tom's stroke takes him off the mic and everyone rallies for weeks — until the triumphant in-person return: "a turduckin of podcasts," the whole crew together for the first time.
Pencil-Gate, POG-Gate, the Podcastaways Oath, and mascot Tiki Ted tease a bigger future. The Thanksgiving finale signs off: "We'll see you on Season 4."
Season 4 — The Transition (Dec 2024 – Jul 2025)
Season 4 opens on Gary's fake resignation and triumphant return from "the trenches with Madison." The Venezia sailing delivers "I'm not Tom, damn it."
"Pineapple" becomes the safe word, Jenn's Grand Princess review makes the cheating official, Aspen Sage retires the hot-dog question, Tom goes public with his recovery, and The Tom & Jenn Show airs solo.
Ghost-Trevor lip-reads a whole episode, the $5 soundboard arrives, the mayo crusade and toilet-drain mystery rage, and Trevor is ruled a permanent blue card.
FRGC #3 sails the Luminosa — whales off Juneau, OG listeners aboard, the Barmores hosting — and FRGC #4 on the Jubilee is announced before the glow fades.
Carnival's loyalty overhaul lands like a gut punch and gets a full Titanic-parody funeral. The crew grieves its way to acceptance — and starts teasing "changes coming in August."
Celebration Key opens, and in the finale the crew drop "Carnival Cruising" from the name for good. "You will always be a podcast away."
Season 5 — Same Chaos, New Name (Aug 2025 – present)
"Welcome to The Podcastaways!" airs with no new music and a mouth-drummed theme. The core trio of Trevor, Tom & Jenn settles in; the season number goes to a Facebook poll.
Tim & Brando's Australian takeover episodes begin, Frozen Jenn fights her internet, and Tyler ships out to work for Norwegian.
Casino comps with Annie McCone, the Great Bra Debate, and the Facebook group gets nautical honorary ranks: Lord of the Lido, Baron of the Buffet.
The milestone sails by unremarked, as is tradition.
The April Fools Margaritaville prank lands April 1; the five-year anniversary episode grades Episode 1's tips on April 25.
John Heald steps back after decades as the north star, RelaxAway Half Moon Cay opens, and the show cruises on toward FRGC #4. You will always be a podcast away.
Want the full story?
Every episode is broken down in the guide — topics, highlights, and a play button on each one.
📖 Browse the Episode Guide →